Jose Guinea Montalvo's Profile
 
Contributions
regular ratings:8
total ratings:8
average rating:30.88
median rating:30
Regular Charts
By Total Rating (Regular)
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 36.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981) 34.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 01.1", 5 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2008) 33.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 4.207 - Fulsome Sweetness - Quietly Brooding Peat", 19 yo. (d: 1995) 30.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "Cask Strength, Batch 18", (b: 2012) 29.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "Hepburn's Choice - John McCrae", 24 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2016) 29.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226 - Teddy Boys At The Beach", 15 yo. (d: 2000) 29.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", (b: 2018) 27.00 1
By Nose (Regular)
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
5 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 8.00 1
6 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
7 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
 
By Taste (Regular)
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 8.00 1
5 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 8.00 1
6 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 7.00 1
 
By Finish (Regular)
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 6.00 1
 
By Balance (Regular)
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 6.00 1
 
By Controversy (Regular)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 3.3 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 3.1 1
3 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 2.6 1
4 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 1.6 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.3 1
6 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 0.8 1
7 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 0.4 1
8 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Regular)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
2 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 0.4 1
3 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 0.8 1
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.3 1
5 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 1.6 1
6 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 2.6 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 3.1 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 3.3 1
Combined Charts
By Total Rating (Combined)
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 36.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981) 34.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 01.1", 5 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2008) 33.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 4.207 - Fulsome Sweetness - Quietly Brooding Peat", 19 yo. (d: 1995) 30.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "Cask Strength, Batch 18", (b: 2012) 29.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "Hepburn's Choice - John McCrae", 24 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2016) 29.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226 - Teddy Boys At The Beach", 15 yo. (d: 2000) 29.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", (b: 2018) 27.00 1
By Nose (Combined)
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
5 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 8.00 1
6 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
7 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
 
By Taste (Combined)
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 8.00 1
5 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 8.00 1
6 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 7.00 1
 
By Finish (Combined)
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 6.00 1
 
By Balance (Combined)
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
4 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
5 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 7.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 7.00 1
7 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 7.00 1
8 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 6.00 1
 
By Controversy (Combined)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 3.3 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 3.1 1
3 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 2.6 1
4 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 1.6 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.3 1
6 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 0.8 1
7 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 0.4 1
8 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Combined)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
2 Indian Amrut "CS #18", 0.4 1
3 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 0.8 1
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.3 1
5 Scotch Balvenie "HC MCrae", 24 yo. 1.6 1
6 Scotch Glenlivet "Code", 2.6 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo. 3.1 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "SMWS 53.226", 15 yo. 3.3 1
Whisky Buddies & Foes
Whisky Buddies
(5 or more comparable ratings)
# Buddy Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Andrew Pearce 2.6 9
2 David Drell 3.0 6
3 Stuart Campbell 3.2 5
4 Andrew Hutchings 4.6 5
5 Jane Austen 4.8 9
6 Jason McDade 5.1 7
 
Whisky Foes
(5 or more comparable ratings)
# Foe Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Jason McDade 5.1 7
2 Jane Austen 4.8 9
3 Andrew Hutchings 4.6 5
4 Stuart Campbell 3.2 5
5 David Drell 3.0 6
6 Andrew Pearce 2.6 9
Graphs