UBWS - Member Profile for Douglas Sherman

bottles donated:	1
regular ratings:	20
total ratings:	20
average rating:	30.20
median rating:	30

By Nose (Combined) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	nose	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	10.00	1
2		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	9.00	1
3		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	9.00	1
4		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	9.00	1
5		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	9.00	1
6		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
7		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	8.00	1
8		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	8.00	1
9		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	8.00	1
10		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	7.00	1
11		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Excl.", 21 yo.	7.00	1
12		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	7.00	1
13		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	6.00	1
14		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	6.00	1
15		Bunnahabhain "SigVin K&L Excl.", 10 yo.	6.00	1
16		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	6.00	1
17		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	6.00	1
18		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	6.00	1
19		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	6.00	1
20		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	6.00	1

By Taste (Combined) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	taste	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	9.00	1
2		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	9.00	1
3		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	9.00	1
4		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Excl.", 21 yo.	9.00	1
5		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	9.00	1
6		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
7		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	8.00	1
8		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	8.00	1
9		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
10		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	8.00	1
11		Bunnahabhain "SigVin K&L Excl.", 10 yo.	8.00	1
12		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	8.00	1
13		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	8.00	1
14		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	7.00	1
15		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	7.00	1
16		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	7.00	1
17		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	7.00	1
18		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	7.00	1
19		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	6.00	1
20		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	5.00	1

By Finish (Combined) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	finish	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	9.00	1
2		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	9.00	1
3		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	9.00	1
4		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	8.00	1
5		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Excl.", 21 yo.	8.00	1
6		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	8.00	1
7		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
8		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	8.00	1
9		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	8.00	1
10		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	8.00	1
11		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	8.00	1
12		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	7.00	1
13		Bunnahabhain "SigVin K&L Excl.", 10 yo.	7.00	1
14		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	7.00	1
15		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	7.00	1
16		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	7.00	1
17		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	6.00	1
18		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	6.00	1
19		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	6.00	1
20		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	4.00	1

By Balance (Combined) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	balance	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	10.00	1
2		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	9.00	1
3		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	9.00	1
4		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Excl.", 21 yo.	9.00	1
5		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	9.00	1
6		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
7		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	8.00	1
8		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	8.00	1
9		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	8.00	1
10		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	8.00	1
11		Bunnahabhain "SigVin K&L Excl.", 10 yo.	8.00	1
12		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	7.00	1
13		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	7.00	1
14		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	7.00	1
15		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	7.00	1
16		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	7.00	1
17		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	7.00	1
18		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	6.00	1
19		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	6.00	1
20		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	6.00	1

By Controversy (Combined) variance against average Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	variance	ratings
1		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	4.8	1
2		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	4.7	1
3		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	4.7	1
4		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	4.7	1
5		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	4.5	1
6		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	4.4	1
7		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	3.9	1
8		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	3.8	1
9		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	3.8	1
10		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	3.4	1
11		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	3.1	1
12		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	2.1	1
13		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	2.1	1
14		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	1.8	1
15		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	1.6	1
16		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	1.0	1
17		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	0.4	1
18		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	0.0	1

By Consensus (Combined) variance against average Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	variance	ratings
1		Miltonduff "OP K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	0.0	1
2		Old Pulteney "K&L #231", 13 yo.	0.4	1
3		Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	1.0	1
4		Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo.	1.6	1
5		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo.	1.8	1
6		Ledaig "Marsala Finish Ltd. Rel.", 19 yo.	2.1	1
7		Bruichladdich "Octo 1.1", 5 yo.	2.1	1
8		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	3.1	1
9		Blair Athol "OMC K&L Excl.", 23 yo.	3.4	1
10		Balvenie "SB Sherry", 15 yo.	3.8	1
11		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	3.8	1
12		Kavalan "Solist K&L Excl. Sherry",	3.9	1
13		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015",	4.4	1
14		Bruichladdich "Micro-Prov K&L", 8 yo.	4.5	1
15		Springbank "O&R Platinum K&L Excl.", 22 yo.	4.7	1
16		Bowmore "OP K&L Excl.", 20 yo.	4.7	1
17		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	4.7	1
18		Octomore 9.1, 5 yo.	4.8	1

Whisky Buddies (5 or more comparable ratings) Top ↑
#	Buddy	Variance (Pts)	Shared Ratings
1	Kolja Erman	2.4	15
2	Stuart Campbell	2.5	6
3	Andrew Pilgrim	2.8	5
4	Gary Trousdale	3.2	5
5	Dmitry Shklyar	3.6	7
6	Jim Leuper	3.8	13
7	Tim Sexton	4.3	8
8	Joyce Lomax	4.6	5
9	Maragaret Rigotti	4.6	5
10	Jason McDade	4.8	18
11	Jane Austen	4.8	25
12	Andrew Pearce	4.8	25
13	Topher Hughes	5.2	9
14	Garen Calac	5.4	7
15	Andrew Hutchings	5.5	12
16	Thaddaeus Wassyinger	6.3	6
17	John Doe	6.4	5

Whisky Foes (5 or more comparable ratings) Top ↑
#	Foe	Variance (Pts)	Shared Ratings
1	John Doe	6.4	5
2	Thaddaeus Wassyinger	6.3	6
3	Andrew Hutchings	5.5	12
4	Garen Calac	5.4	7
5	Topher Hughes	5.2	9
6	Andrew Pearce	4.8	25
7	Jane Austen	4.8	25
8	Jason McDade	4.8	18
9	Maragaret Rigotti	4.6	5
10	Joyce Lomax	4.6	5
11	Tim Sexton	4.3	8
12	Jim Leuper	3.8	13
13	Dmitry Shklyar	3.6	7
14	Gary Trousdale	3.2	5
15	Andrew Pilgrim	2.8	5
16	Stuart Campbell	2.5	6
17	Kolja Erman	2.4	15

#	Whisky	Date
1	Glenfiddich "Our Amontillado Sherry Cask Finish", 12 yo.	12/12/22

By Total Rating (Regular) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	rating	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	38.00	1
2		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981)	35.00	1
3		Bruichladdich "Octomore 01.1", 5 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2008)	34.00	1
4		Miltonduff "Old Particular K&L Excl.", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	33.00	1
5		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Exclusive", 21 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2019)	33.00	1
6		Imperial "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2014)	33.00	1
7		Ledaig "Marsala Cask Finish - Limited Release", 19 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2016)	33.00	1
8		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Exclusive", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	33.00	1
9		Old Pulteney "K&L Excl. Cask #231", 13 yo. (d: 2004,b: 2018)	31.00	1
10		Kavalan "Solist - K&L Excl. Sherry Cask 3100125005A", (b: 2017)	30.00	1
11		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	30.00	1
12		Octomore "09.1 Dialogos", 5 yo. (d: 2012,b: 2018)	30.00	1
13		Bunnahabhain "Signatory Vintage K&L Excl.", 10 yo. (d: 2012,b: 2022)	29.00	1
14		Bruichladdich "Micro-Provenance Series K&L Excl.", 8 yo. (d: 2003,b: 2011)	29.00	1
15		Bowmore "Old Particular K&L Excl.", 20 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2017)	28.00	1
16		Blair Athol "Old Malt Cask K&L Excl.", 23 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2018)	27.00	1
17		Springbank "Old & Rare Platinum Selection K&L Exclusive", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2018)	27.00	1
18		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	25.00	1
19		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", (b: 2016)	25.00	1
20		Balvenie "Single Barrel Sherry Cask", 15 yo.	21.00	1

By Total Rating (Combined) Top ↑
#	Country	Whisky	rating	ratings
1		Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution", 5 yo.	38.00	1
2		Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981)	35.00	1
3		Bruichladdich "Octomore 01.1", 5 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2008)	34.00	1
4		Miltonduff "Old Particular K&L Excl.", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	33.00	1
5		Ledaig "Chieftain's K&L Exclusive", 21 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2019)	33.00	1
6		Imperial "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2014)	33.00	1
7		Ledaig "Marsala Cask Finish - Limited Release", 19 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2016)	33.00	1
8		Bowmore "Sovereign K&L Exclusive", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	33.00	1
9		Old Pulteney "K&L Excl. Cask #231", 13 yo. (d: 2004,b: 2018)	31.00	1
10		Kavalan "Solist - K&L Excl. Sherry Cask 3100125005A", (b: 2017)	30.00	1
11		Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo.	30.00	1
12		Octomore "09.1 Dialogos", 5 yo. (d: 2012,b: 2018)	30.00	1
13		Bunnahabhain "Signatory Vintage K&L Excl.", 10 yo. (d: 2012,b: 2022)	29.00	1
14		Bruichladdich "Micro-Provenance Series K&L Excl.", 8 yo. (d: 2003,b: 2011)	29.00	1
15		Bowmore "Old Particular K&L Excl.", 20 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2017)	28.00	1
16		Blair Athol "Old Malt Cask K&L Excl.", 23 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2018)	27.00	1
17		Springbank "Old & Rare Platinum Selection K&L Exclusive", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2018)	27.00	1
18		Mortlach "Faultline K&L Excl.", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017)	25.00	1
19		UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", (b: 2016)	25.00	1
20		Balvenie "Single Barrel Sherry Cask", 15 yo.	21.00	1