Andrew Pilgrim's Profile
 
Contributions
bottles donated:22
regular ratings:57
total ratings:57
average rating:25.81
median rating:28
Bottle Donations
# Whisky Date
22 Suntory "Hibiki", 17 yo. 10/28/19
21 Talisker "Dark Storm", (b: 2014) 02/11/19
20 Laphroaig "Quarter Cask", 05/19/17
19 Bowmore, 16 yo. (d: 1992,b: 2008) 06/22/12
18 Balvenie "Signature", 12 yo. 05/07/10
17 Bowmore, 18 yo. 03/19/10
16 Bruichladdich "Cuvee A Paulliac Bordeaux 1st Growth Series", 16 yo. 02/24/10
15 Talisker, 10 yo. 10/09/09
14 Scapa "The Orcadian", 16 yo. 05/08/09
13 Suntory "Yamazaki", 18 yo. 03/11/09
Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo.
Bowmore "Ltd.Ed. - Port Matured", 16 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2007)
Bowmore "Mariner", 15 yo.
Bowmore, 25 yo.
The Famous Grouse, 18 yo.
Highland Park, 15 yo.
Kirin "Fuji Sanroku - 50 deg",
Macallan "Fine Oak", 10 yo.
Macallan "Fine Oak", 12 yo.
Scapa, 14 yo.
Suntory "Hibiki", 17 yo.
Suntory "Yamazaki", 12 yo.
Regular Charts
By Total Rating (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 39.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "Cask Strength Batch 2", 35.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 15 yo. (d: 1998,b: 2014) 35.00 1
4 English The English Whisky Co. "Peated", 35.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask Matured", 4 yo. (d: 2011,b: 2015) 35.00 1
6 Scotch Imperial "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2014) 33.00 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 33.00 1
8 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist - Fino Sherry Cask S060814037", 33.00 1
9 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", (b: 2016) 33.00 1
10 Scotch Lagavulin "Cask Strength #14 - 2014", 12 yo. (b: 2014) 32.00 1
11 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8 - Youthful and zesty - yet complex", 7 yo. (d: 2006,b: 2013) 32.00 1
12 Scotch Glen Keith "Hepburn's Choice K&L Exclusive", 24 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2016) 32.00 1
13 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 31.33 3
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", (b: 2015) 31.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L Excl. Pedro Ximenez Sherry Finish", 27 yo. (d: 1984,b: 2012) 31.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 31.00 1
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte" "SMWS 127.31 - Rite of passage", 10 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2012) 31.00 1
18 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage Single Barrel Cask Strength", 31 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2011) 31.00 1
19 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 4.207 - Fulsome Sweetness - Quietly Brooding Peat", 19 yo. (d: 1995) 30.00 1
20 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. (d: 1978,b: 2004) 30.00 1
21 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 29.50 2
22 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", (b: 2015) 29.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. (d: 1965,b: 2005) 28.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "Signatory Vintage", 11 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2008) 28.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", (b: 2016) 28.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sovereign K&L Exclusive - John McCrae", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017) 28.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "Limited 200th Anniversary Edition", 8 yo. (b: 2016) 28.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Exclusive Malts", 11 yo. (d: 2004,b: 2015) 28.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981) 28.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 27.00 1
31 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 27.00 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. (d: 1999) 27.00 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 27.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 25.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 24.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2002) 24.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 24.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 24.00 1
39 Indian Amrut, 23.00 1
40 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity [3] - Edition_3.10", (b: 2011) 21.00 1
41 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 20.00 1
42 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 20.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 20.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 18.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 18.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 14.00 1
47 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 14.00 1
48 Irish Tyrconnell, 13.00 1
49 Scotch Dunlivet, 13.00 1
50 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 13.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. (d: 1990,b: 2008) 13.00 1
52 Scotch Auchentoshan "A.D. Rattray Cask Collection", 20 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2011) 13.00 1
53 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 12.00 1
54 American L&G Woodford Reserve "Distiller's Select", 6 yo. 12.00 1
By Nose (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 9.00 1
4 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 8.00 3
5 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 8.00 1
6 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 8.00 1
7 English English Whisky "Peated", 8.00 1
8 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
9 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
15 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 2
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 7.00 1
19 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 7.00 1
20 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 7.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 7.00 1
23 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
24 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
29 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 7.00 1
30 Indian Amrut, 7.00 1
31 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 6.00 1
32 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 6.00 1
33 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 6.00 1
34 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 6.00 1
35 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 6.00 1
36 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
39 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 5.00 1
40 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
41 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 5.00 1
42 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 4.00 1
43 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.00 1
44 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 4.00 1
45 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.00 1
46 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 3.00 1
47 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 3.00 1
48 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 3.00 1
49 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
50 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
52 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
53 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 2.00 1
54 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 9.00 1
7 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
8 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
9 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
14 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
15 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
18 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 8.00 1
20 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 8.00 1
21 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
22 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 7.67 3
23 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.50 2
24 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
25 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
26 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
27 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
32 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
33 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 7.00 1
34 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 7.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 6.00 1
39 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.00 1
40 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 6.00 1
41 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 6.00 1
42 Indian Amrut, 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 4.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 4.00 1
47 Scotch Dunlivet, 4.00 1
48 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.00 1
49 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 3.00 1
50 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
52 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 3.00 1
53 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
54 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Finish (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 2
7 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 8.00 1
8 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
9 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 8.00 1
18 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 8.00 1
19 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 7.33 3
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 7.00 1
22 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
32 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
33 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 6.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.00 1
39 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 6.00 1
40 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 6.00 1
41 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.00 1
42 Indian Amrut, 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.00 1
46 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 4.00 1
47 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 3.00 1
48 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 3.00 1
49 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
50 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
51 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 3.00 1
52 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
53 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 3.00 1
54 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
 
By Balance (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
7 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 9.00 1
8 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 9.00 1
9 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 8.33 3
10 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
18 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
19 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 2
20 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 7.00 1
22 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 6.00 1
39 Indian Amrut, 6.00 1
40 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 5.00 1
41 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 5.00 1
42 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 5.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 4.00 1
47 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 4.00 1
48 Irish Tyrconnell, 4.00 1
49 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 4.00 1
50 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 4.00 1
51 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 4.00 1
52 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
53 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
54 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Controversy (Regular)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 13.7 1
2 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 11.0 1
3 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 9.4 1
4 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 9.3 1
5 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 9.2 1
6 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 9.2 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 8.9 1
8 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 8.4 1
9 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 7.8 1
10 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 7.5 1
11 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.9 1
12 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 5.2 1
13 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.1 1
14 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.7 1
15 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.6 1
16 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 4.4 1
17 English English Whisky "Peated", 4.3 1
18 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.6 1
19 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 3.4 1
20 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 3.3 1
21 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 3.3 1
22 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 3.3 1
23 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 3.2 1
24 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 3.2 1
25 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.1 1
26 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 2.8 1
27 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 2.5 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 2.5 1
29 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 2.4 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 2.1 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 2.1 1
32 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 2.0 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 2.0 1
34 Indian Amrut, 1.9 1
35 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 1.9 2
36 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.7 1
37 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 1.7 1
38 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 1.6 1
39 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 1.4 1
40 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 1.3 1
41 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 1.2 1
42 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 0.9 1
43 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 0.7 1
44 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 0.4 1
45 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
46 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 0.4 1
47 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 0.3 3
48 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 0.3 1
49 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 0.1 1
50 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 0.1 1
51 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Regular)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 0.1 1
3 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 0.1 1
4 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 0.3 1
5 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 0.3 3
6 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 0.4 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
8 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 0.4 1
9 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 0.7 1
10 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 0.9 1
11 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 1.2 1
12 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 1.3 1
13 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 1.4 1
14 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 1.6 1
15 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 1.7 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.7 1
17 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 1.9 2
18 Indian Amrut, 1.9 1
19 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 2.0 1
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 2.0 1
21 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 2.1 1
22 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 2.1 1
23 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 2.4 1
24 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 2.5 1
25 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 2.5 1
26 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 2.8 1
27 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.1 1
28 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 3.2 1
29 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 3.2 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 3.3 1
31 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 3.3 1
32 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 3.3 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 3.4 1
34 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.6 1
35 English English Whisky "Peated", 4.3 1
36 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 4.4 1
37 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.6 1
38 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.7 1
39 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.1 1
40 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 5.2 1
41 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.9 1
42 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 7.5 1
43 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 7.8 1
44 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 8.4 1
45 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 8.9 1
46 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 9.2 1
47 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 9.2 1
48 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 9.3 1
49 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 9.4 1
50 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 11.0 1
51 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 13.7 1
Combined Charts
By Total Rating (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 39.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "Cask Strength Batch 2", 35.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 15 yo. (d: 1998,b: 2014) 35.00 1
4 English The English Whisky Co. "Peated", 35.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask Matured", 4 yo. (d: 2011,b: 2015) 35.00 1
6 Scotch Imperial "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2014) 33.00 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 33.00 1
8 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist - Fino Sherry Cask S060814037", 33.00 1
9 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", (b: 2016) 33.00 1
10 Scotch Lagavulin "Cask Strength #14 - 2014", 12 yo. (b: 2014) 32.00 1
11 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8 - Youthful and zesty - yet complex", 7 yo. (d: 2006,b: 2013) 32.00 1
12 Scotch Glen Keith "Hepburn's Choice K&L Exclusive", 24 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2016) 32.00 1
13 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 31.33 3
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", (b: 2015) 31.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L Excl. Pedro Ximenez Sherry Finish", 27 yo. (d: 1984,b: 2012) 31.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 31.00 1
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte" "SMWS 127.31 - Rite of passage", 10 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2012) 31.00 1
18 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage Single Barrel Cask Strength", 31 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2011) 31.00 1
19 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 4.207 - Fulsome Sweetness - Quietly Brooding Peat", 19 yo. (d: 1995) 30.00 1
20 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. (d: 1978,b: 2004) 30.00 1
21 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 29.50 2
22 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", (b: 2015) 29.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. (d: 1965,b: 2005) 28.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "Signatory Vintage", 11 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2008) 28.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", (b: 2016) 28.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sovereign K&L Exclusive - John McCrae", 22 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2017) 28.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "Limited 200th Anniversary Edition", 8 yo. (b: 2016) 28.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Exclusive Malts", 11 yo. (d: 2004,b: 2015) 28.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. Signatory Vintage", 33 yo. (d: 1981) 28.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 27.00 1
31 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 27.00 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. (d: 1999) 27.00 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 27.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 25.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 24.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2002) 24.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 24.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 24.00 1
39 Indian Amrut, 23.00 1
40 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity [3] - Edition_3.10", (b: 2011) 21.00 1
41 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 20.00 1
42 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 20.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 20.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 18.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 18.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 14.00 1
47 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 14.00 1
48 Irish Tyrconnell, 13.00 1
49 Scotch Dunlivet, 13.00 1
50 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 13.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. (d: 1990,b: 2008) 13.00 1
52 Scotch Auchentoshan "A.D. Rattray Cask Collection", 20 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2011) 13.00 1
53 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 12.00 1
54 American L&G Woodford Reserve "Distiller's Select", 6 yo. 12.00 1
By Nose (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
3 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 9.00 1
4 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 8.00 3
5 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 8.00 1
6 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 8.00 1
7 English English Whisky "Peated", 8.00 1
8 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
9 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
15 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 2
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 7.00 1
19 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 7.00 1
20 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 7.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 7.00 1
23 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
24 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
29 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 7.00 1
30 Indian Amrut, 7.00 1
31 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 6.00 1
32 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 6.00 1
33 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 6.00 1
34 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 6.00 1
35 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 6.00 1
36 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
39 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 5.00 1
40 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
41 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 5.00 1
42 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 4.00 1
43 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.00 1
44 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 4.00 1
45 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.00 1
46 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 3.00 1
47 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 3.00 1
48 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 3.00 1
49 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
50 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
52 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
53 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 2.00 1
54 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 9.00 1
7 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
8 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 8.00 1
9 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
14 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
15 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
18 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 8.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 8.00 1
20 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 8.00 1
21 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 8.00 1
22 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 7.67 3
23 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.50 2
24 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
25 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
26 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
27 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
32 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
33 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 7.00 1
34 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 7.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 6.00 1
39 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.00 1
40 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 6.00 1
41 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 6.00 1
42 Indian Amrut, 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 4.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 4.00 1
47 Scotch Dunlivet, 4.00 1
48 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.00 1
49 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 3.00 1
50 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
51 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
52 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 3.00 1
53 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
54 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Finish (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 2
7 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 8.00 1
8 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
9 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 8.00 1
18 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 8.00 1
19 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 7.33 3
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 7.00 1
22 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
32 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
33 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 6.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.00 1
39 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 6.00 1
40 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 6.00 1
41 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.00 1
42 Indian Amrut, 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.00 1
46 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 4.00 1
47 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 3.00 1
48 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 3.00 1
49 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.00 1
50 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
51 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 3.00 1
52 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 3.00 1
53 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 3.00 1
54 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
 
By Balance (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 9.00 1
4 English English Whisky "Peated", 9.00 1
5 Scotch Kilchoman "Madeira Cask", 4 yo. 9.00 1
6 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 9.00 1
7 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 9.00 1
8 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 9.00 1
9 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 8.33 3
10 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 8.00 1
13 Scotch Glen Keith "HC K&L Excl.", 24 yo. 8.00 1
14 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 8.00 1
15 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 8.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
17 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 8.00 1
18 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
19 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 2
20 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 7.00 1
22 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 7.00 1
23 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 7.00 1
24 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 7.00 1
25 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 7.00 1
26 Scotch Balvenie "Sov. K&L Excl. J.McC", 22 yo. 7.00 1
27 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 7.00 1
28 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 7.00 1
29 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 7.00 1
30 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 7.00 1
31 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 7.00 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 7.00 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 7.00 1
34 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.00 1
35 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 6.00 1
36 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 6.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 6.00 1
38 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 6.00 1
39 Indian Amrut, 6.00 1
40 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 5.00 1
41 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 5.00 1
42 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 5.00 1
43 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 5.00 1
44 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 5.00 1
45 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 5.00 1
46 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 4.00 1
47 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 4.00 1
48 Irish Tyrconnell, 4.00 1
49 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 4.00 1
50 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 4.00 1
51 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 4.00 1
52 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.00 1
53 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 3.00 1
54 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Controversy (Combined)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 13.7 1
2 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 11.0 1
3 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 9.4 1
4 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 9.3 1
5 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 9.2 1
6 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 9.2 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 8.9 1
8 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 8.4 1
9 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 7.8 1
10 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 7.5 1
11 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.9 1
12 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 5.2 1
13 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.1 1
14 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.7 1
15 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.6 1
16 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 4.4 1
17 English English Whisky "Peated", 4.3 1
18 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.6 1
19 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 3.4 1
20 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 3.3 1
21 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 3.3 1
22 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 3.3 1
23 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 3.2 1
24 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 3.2 1
25 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.1 1
26 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 2.8 1
27 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 2.5 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 2.5 1
29 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 2.4 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 2.1 1
31 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 2.1 1
32 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 2.0 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 2.0 1
34 Indian Amrut, 1.9 1
35 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 1.9 2
36 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.7 1
37 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 1.7 1
38 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 1.6 1
39 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 1.4 1
40 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 1.3 1
41 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 1.2 1
42 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 0.9 1
43 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 0.7 1
44 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 0.4 1
45 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
46 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 0.4 1
47 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 0.3 3
48 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 0.3 1
49 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 0.1 1
50 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 0.1 1
51 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Combined)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Highland Park "SMWS 5.207", 19 yo. 0.0 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Perpetuum", 0.1 1
3 Scotch BenRiach "K&L PX", 27 yo. 0.1 1
4 Scotch Lagavulin, 16 yo. 0.3 1
5 Scotch Longrow "Red - Pinot Noir", 12 yo. 0.3 3
6 Scotch Lagavulin "CS 2014", 12 yo. 0.4 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
8 Scotch Balblair "SMWS 70.8", 7 yo. 0.4 1
9 Scotch Glen Ord "The Classic Cask", 40 yo. 0.7 1
10 Irish Powers "Gold Label", 5 yo. 0.9 1
11 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 1.2 1
12 Scotch Benromach, 25 yo. 1.3 1
13 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2015", 1.4 1
14 Scotch Imperial "K&L Excl. SigVin", 18 yo. 1.6 1
15 Scotch GlenDronach "CS #2", 1.7 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Octomore 07.1", 5 yo. 1.7 1
17 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 1.9 2
18 Indian Amrut, 1.9 1
19 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist Fino", 2.0 1
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC5 Evolution", 5 yo. 2.0 1
21 Scotch Ardbeg "Dark Cove", 2.1 1
22 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC - SMWS 127.31", 10 yo. 2.1 1
23 Scotch Rosebank "Old Malt Cask", 22 yo. 2.4 1
24 Scotch Balvenie "DoubleWood", 17 yo. 2.5 1
25 Scotch Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo. 2.5 1
26 Scotch Ardbeg "Galileo", 12 yo. 2.8 1
27 Irish Tyrconnell, 3.1 1
28 Scotch Lagavulin "200th Anniv.Ltd.Ed.", 8 yo. 3.2 1
29 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 3.2 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "Excl. Malts", 11 yo. 3.3 1
31 Scotch Laphroaig "K&L Excl. SV", 15 yo. 3.3 1
32 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2014", 3.3 1
33 Taiwanese Kavalan "Solist", 3.4 1
34 Scotch Dunlivet, 3.6 1
35 English English Whisky "Peated", 4.3 1
36 Scotch Caol Ila, 25 yo. 4.4 1
37 American Russell's Reserve, 6 yo. 4.6 1
38 Scotch Auchentoshan, 10 yo. 4.7 1
39 German Alt Enderle "Neccarus", 8 yo. 5.1 1
40 Scotch Glenlivet "K&L Excl. SigVin", 33 yo. 5.2 1
41 Canadian Forty Creek "Barrel Select", 6 yo. 6.9 1
42 American Eagle Rare, 17 yo. 7.5 1
43 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 7.8 1
44 Scotch GlenDronach "Allardice", 18 yo. 8.4 1
45 Scotch Bruichladdich "WMDII - Yellow Submarine", 14 yo. 8.9 1
46 Scotch Glenrothes "Select Reserve", 9.2 1
47 American Buffalo Trace "Bacon", 9.2 1
48 American L&G Woodford Reserve "DS", 6 yo. 9.3 1
49 Scotch Glenfiddich "Vintage Cask", 9.4 1
50 Scotch Longrow "Red", 11 yo. 11.0 1
51 Scotch Auchentoshan "AD Rattray", 20 yo. 13.7 1
Whisky Buddies & Foes
Whisky Buddies
(5 or more comparable ratings)
Top ↑
# Buddy Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Scott Churchman 2.4 5
2 Alex Powell 2.8 5
3 Douglas Sherman 2.8 5
4 Unknown Donor 3.1 15
5 Joyce Lomax 3.4 6
6 Jane Austen 3.4 16
7 Kai Wang 3.6 11
8 Tim Sexton 3.7 11
9 Jim Leuper 4.1 43
10 Andrew Hutchings 4.2 9
11 Stuart Campbell 4.2 51
12 Robert Crawford 4.3 16
13 Andrew Pearce 4.3 22
14 Ben Kwa 4.6 9
15 Gary Trousdale 4.6 9
16 Corey Hels 4.8 8
17 David Drell 4.8 33
18 Kolja Erman 5.0 60
19 JC Alvarez 5.0 5
20 Ray Forziati 5.0 5
21 Jason McDade 5.1 25
22 Barry Dempsey 5.2 5
23 Sean Looper 5.3 8
24 Sean Cole 5.3 10
25 Josh Richards 5.4 16
26 Graham Whitted 5.8 5
27 Rick Hromadka 5.8 5
28 Dmitry Shklyar 5.9 8
29 David Lawson 5.9 18
30 Doug Seiden 5.9 10
31 Dan Bunn 6.0 5
32 Matt Schmidt 6.0 11
33 Eric Walters 6.2 5
34 Alex Gurevich 6.6 24
35 Brent Watkins 6.6 8
36 Anthony Lanni 7.2 17
37 Tom Owens 7.3 37
38 Danik Thomas 7.6 5
39 Mike Brainerd 7.7 7
40 Will Bilton 8.0 5
41 Andy Romine 8.3 10
42 Stan Haptas 8.6 8
 
Whisky Foes
(5 or more comparable ratings)
Top ↑
# Foe Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Stan Haptas 8.6 8
2 Andy Romine 8.3 10
3 Will Bilton 8.0 5
4 Mike Brainerd 7.7 7
5 Danik Thomas 7.6 5
6 Tom Owens 7.3 37
7 Anthony Lanni 7.2 17
8 Brent Watkins 6.6 8
9 Alex Gurevich 6.6 24
10 Eric Walters 6.2 5
11 Matt Schmidt 6.0 11
12 Dan Bunn 6.0 5
13 Doug Seiden 5.9 10
14 David Lawson 5.9 18
15 Dmitry Shklyar 5.9 8
16 Rick Hromadka 5.8 5
17 Graham Whitted 5.8 5
18 Josh Richards 5.4 16
19 Sean Cole 5.3 10
20 Sean Looper 5.3 8
21 Barry Dempsey 5.2 5
22 Jason McDade 5.1 25
23 Ray Forziati 5.0 5
24 JC Alvarez 5.0 5
25 Kolja Erman 5.0 60
26 David Drell 4.8 33
27 Corey Hels 4.8 8
28 Gary Trousdale 4.6 9
29 Ben Kwa 4.6 9
30 Andrew Pearce 4.3 22
31 Robert Crawford 4.3 16
32 Stuart Campbell 4.2 51
33 Andrew Hutchings 4.2 9
34 Jim Leuper 4.1 43
35 Tim Sexton 3.7 11
36 Kai Wang 3.6 11
37 Jane Austen 3.4 16
38 Joyce Lomax 3.4 6
39 Unknown Donor 3.1 15
40 Douglas Sherman 2.8 5
41 Alex Powell 2.8 5
42 Scott Churchman 2.4 5
Graphs