David Gardner's Profile
 
Contributions
bottles donated:3
regular ratings:5
total ratings:5
average rating:25.40
median rating:31
Bottle Donations
# Whisky Date
3 Caol Ila "James MacArthur", 10yo, 10 yo. (d: 2000,b: 2011) 01/30/15
2 Edradour "Straight From The Cask - Marsala Cask Finish", 11 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2014) 09/26/14
1 Highland Park "MacPhail's Collection", 8 yo. 12/06/13
Regular Charts
By Total Rating (Regular)
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "Signatory Vintage K&L Excl.", 20 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2015) 33.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 31.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Straight From The Cask - Marsala Cask Finish", 11 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2014) 31.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu "On The Way", (b: 2013) 24.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 8.00 1
By Nose (Regular)
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 3.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Regular)
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 7.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 7.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 4.00 1
 
By Finish (Regular)
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 1.00 1
 
By Balance (Regular)
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 1.00 1
 
By Controversy (Regular)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 16.4 1
2 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 3.1 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 1.1 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 0.9 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
 
By Consensus (Regular)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
2 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 0.9 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 1.1 1
4 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 3.1 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 16.4 1
Combined Charts
By Total Rating (Combined)
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "Signatory Vintage K&L Excl.", 20 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2015) 33.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Port Charlotte PC10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 31.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Straight From The Cask - Marsala Cask Finish", 11 yo. (d: 2002,b: 2014) 31.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu "On The Way", (b: 2013) 24.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 8.00 1
By Nose (Combined)
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 3.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Combined)
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 7.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 7.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 4.00 1
 
By Finish (Combined)
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 1.00 1
 
By Balance (Combined)
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 8.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 8.00 1
3 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 8.00 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 7.00 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 1.00 1
 
By Controversy (Combined)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 16.4 1
2 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 3.1 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 1.1 1
4 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 0.9 1
5 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
 
By Consensus (Combined)
variance against average
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "PC 10 Tro Na Linntean", 10 yo. 0.4 1
2 Japanese Chichibu OTW, 0.9 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "SigVin K&L Excl.", 20 yo. 1.1 1
4 Scotch Edradour "Marsala Finish", 11 yo. 3.1 1
5 American UBWS "Devil's Share 2013", 16.4 1
Graphs