Kyle Milardo's Profile
 
Contributions
regular ratings:39
total ratings:39
average rating:24.51
median rating:26
Regular Charts
By Total Rating (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity [3] - Edition_3.10", (b: 2011) 35.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage Single Barrel Cask Strength", 31 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2011) 33.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 33.00 1
4 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 32.00 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 32.00 1
6 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Brothers - Ardbeg Matured", 16 yo. (d: 1994,b: 2010) 31.00 1
7 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 31.00 1
8 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 30.00 1
9 Scotch Royal Lochnagar "Distiller's Edition" (Batch RL/00-12W), 12 yo. (d: 2000,b: 2012) 30.00 1
10 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 30.00 1
11 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 29.00 1
12 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 29.00 1
13 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 28.50 2
14 Scotch Rattray's Selection "Batch No.01", 19 yo. 28.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 28.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Exclusive", 19 yo. 28.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 27.00 1
18 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 26.00 1
19 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139 - Why Do Fools Fall In Love", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2013) 26.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 25.00 1
21 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 24.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 24.00 1
23 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 23.00 1
24 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 23.00 1
25 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 22.00 1
26 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 21.00 1
27 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 21.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "A.D. Rattray", 21 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2012) 21.00 1
29 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 20.00 1
30 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 19.00 1
31 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 19.00 1
32 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 19.00 1
33 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 18.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 17.00 1
35 Scotch Clynelish "Signatory Vintage", 11 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2008) 17.00 1
36 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 16.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 8.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 8.00 1
By Nose (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 9.00 1
4 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 9.00 1
5 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 8.00 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 8.00 1
9 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 7.00 1
10 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
11 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
12 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
13 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
14 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 7.00 1
17 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 7.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 6.50 2
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 6.00 1
21 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 6.00 1
23 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
24 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
25 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 6.00 1
26 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 6.00 1
27 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 6.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 5.00 1
29 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 5.00 1
30 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
32 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 5.00 1
35 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.00 1
36 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 3.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 3.00 1
38 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 9.00 1
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 9.00 1
5 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 8.00 2
6 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 8.00 1
9 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 7.00 1
13 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
15 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 6.00 1
19 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
21 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 6.00 1
23 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 6.00 1
24 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
25 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
26 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
27 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 5.00 1
28 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
30 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 4.00 1
31 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 4.00 1
32 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 4.00 1
33 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
34 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 4.00 1
35 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 3.00 1
36 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 3.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Finish (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 8.00 1
4 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
5 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 8.00 1
7 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 8.00 1
8 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 8.00 1
9 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 7.00 2
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 7.00 1
11 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 7.00 1
12 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 1
13 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 7.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.00 1
20 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 7.00 1
22 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 6.00 1
23 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
24 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 6.00 1
25 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 5.00 1
26 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
27 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
30 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 5.00 1
32 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 4.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
35 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.00 1
36 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 1.00 1
 
By Balance (Regular)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 8.00 1
4 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 8.00 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 7.00 2
9 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 7.00 1
10 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 7.00 1
11 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
12 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
13 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
18 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
19 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
21 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 6.00 1
23 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 5.00 1
24 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
25 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
26 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
27 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
28 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
30 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 5.00 1
32 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 4.00 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 4.00 1
35 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 4.00 1
36 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Controversy (Regular)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 14.0 1
2 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 9.8 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 9.3 1
4 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 9.1 1
5 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.1 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 6.6 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 6.3 1
8 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.2 1
9 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 6.1 1
10 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.2 1
11 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 5.1 1
12 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 4.7 1
13 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 4.6 1
14 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 4.6 1
15 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 4.5 1
16 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.0 1
17 German Gruel "Tecker", 3.9 1
18 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.6 1
19 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 3.5 1
20 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 3.0 1
21 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 2.8 1
22 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 2.7 1
23 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 2.7 1
24 American St. George (Lot SM011), 2.6 1
25 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 2.5 1
26 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 1.7 1
27 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 1.2 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 1.2 1
29 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 1.2 1
30 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 0.8 1
31 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 0.7 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 0.6 1
33 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 0.4 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 0.3 2
35 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 0.2 1
36 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Regular)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 0.0 1
2 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 0.2 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 0.3 2
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 0.4 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 0.6 1
6 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 0.7 1
7 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 0.8 1
8 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 1.2 1
9 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 1.2 1
10 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 1.2 1
11 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 1.7 1
12 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 2.5 1
13 American St. George (Lot SM011), 2.6 1
14 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 2.7 1
15 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 2.7 1
16 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 2.8 1
17 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 3.0 1
18 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 3.5 1
19 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.6 1
20 German Gruel "Tecker", 3.9 1
21 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.0 1
22 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 4.5 1
23 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 4.6 1
24 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 4.6 1
25 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 4.7 1
26 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 5.1 1
27 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.2 1
28 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 6.1 1
29 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.2 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 6.3 1
31 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 6.6 1
32 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.1 1
33 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 9.1 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 9.3 1
35 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 9.8 1
36 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 14.0 1
Combined Charts
By Total Rating (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky rating ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity [3] - Edition_3.10", (b: 2011) 35.00 1
2 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L Exclusive Signatory Vintage Single Barrel Cask Strength", 31 yo. (d: 1980,b: 2011) 33.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 33.00 1
4 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 32.00 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 32.00 1
6 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Brothers - Ardbeg Matured", 16 yo. (d: 1994,b: 2010) 31.00 1
7 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 31.00 1
8 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 30.00 1
9 Scotch Royal Lochnagar "Distiller's Edition" (Batch RL/00-12W), 12 yo. (d: 2000,b: 2012) 30.00 1
10 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 30.00 1
11 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 29.00 1
12 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 29.00 1
13 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 28.50 2
14 Scotch Rattray's Selection "Batch No.01", 19 yo. 28.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 28.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Exclusive", 19 yo. 28.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 27.00 1
18 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 26.00 1
19 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139 - Why Do Fools Fall In Love", 18 yo. (d: 1995,b: 2013) 26.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 25.00 1
21 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 24.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 24.00 1
23 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 23.00 1
24 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 23.00 1
25 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 22.00 1
26 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 21.00 1
27 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 21.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "A.D. Rattray", 21 yo. (d: 1991,b: 2012) 21.00 1
29 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 20.00 1
30 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 19.00 1
31 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 19.00 1
32 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 19.00 1
33 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 18.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 17.00 1
35 Scotch Clynelish "Signatory Vintage", 11 yo. (d: 1997,b: 2008) 17.00 1
36 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 16.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 8.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 8.00 1
By Nose (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky nose ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 9.00 1
4 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 9.00 1
5 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 8.00 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 8.00 1
9 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 7.00 1
10 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
11 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
12 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
13 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
14 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 7.00 1
17 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 7.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 6.50 2
20 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 6.00 1
21 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 6.00 1
23 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
24 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
25 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 6.00 1
26 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 6.00 1
27 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 6.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 5.00 1
29 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 5.00 1
30 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
32 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 5.00 1
35 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.00 1
36 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 3.00 1
37 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 3.00 1
38 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
 
By Taste (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky taste ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
2 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 9.00 1
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 9.00 1
5 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 8.00 2
6 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 8.00 1
9 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 8.00 1
10 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 8.00 1
11 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 8.00 1
12 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 7.00 1
13 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
15 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 6.00 1
19 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
21 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 6.00 1
23 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 6.00 1
24 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
25 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
26 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
27 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 5.00 1
28 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
30 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 4.00 1
31 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 4.00 1
32 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 4.00 1
33 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
34 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 4.00 1
35 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 3.00 1
36 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 3.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Finish (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky finish ratings
1 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 9.00 1
2 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 9.00 1
3 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 8.00 1
4 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 8.00 1
5 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
6 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 8.00 1
7 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 8.00 1
8 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 8.00 1
9 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 7.00 2
10 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 7.00 1
11 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 7.00 1
12 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 7.00 1
13 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
18 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 7.00 1
19 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.00 1
20 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 7.00 1
21 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 7.00 1
22 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 6.00 1
23 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
24 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 6.00 1
25 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 5.00 1
26 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
27 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
28 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
30 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 5.00 1
32 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 4.00 1
34 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
35 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.00 1
36 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 1.00 1
 
By Balance (Combined)
Top ↑
# Country Whisky balance ratings
1 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 10.00 1
2 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 9.00 1
3 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 8.00 1
4 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 8.00 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 8.00 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 8.00 1
7 Scotch Compass Box "Great King Street - Artist's Blend", 8.00 1
8 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 7.00 2
9 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 7.00 1
10 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 7.00 1
11 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 7.00 1
12 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 7.00 1
13 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 7.00 1
14 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 7.00 1
15 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 7.00 1
16 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 7.00 1
17 Scotch Kilchoman "Summer 2010 Release", 3 yo. 7.00 1
18 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 6.00 1
19 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 6.00 1
20 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 6.00 1
21 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 6.00 1
22 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 6.00 1
23 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 5.00 1
24 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 5.00 1
25 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 5.00 1
26 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 5.00 1
27 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 5.00 1
28 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 5.00 1
29 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.00 1
30 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 5.00 1
31 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 5.00 1
32 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 5.00 1
33 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 4.00 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 4.00 1
35 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 4.00 1
36 American St. George (Lot SM011), 4.00 1
37 German Gruel "Tecker", 2.00 1
38 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 2.00 1
 
By Controversy (Combined)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 14.0 1
2 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 9.8 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 9.3 1
4 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 9.1 1
5 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.1 1
6 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 6.6 1
7 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 6.3 1
8 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.2 1
9 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 6.1 1
10 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.2 1
11 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 5.1 1
12 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 4.7 1
13 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 4.6 1
14 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 4.6 1
15 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 4.5 1
16 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.0 1
17 German Gruel "Tecker", 3.9 1
18 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.6 1
19 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 3.5 1
20 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 3.0 1
21 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 2.8 1
22 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 2.7 1
23 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 2.7 1
24 American St. George (Lot SM011), 2.6 1
25 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 2.5 1
26 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 1.7 1
27 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 1.2 1
28 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 1.2 1
29 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 1.2 1
30 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 0.8 1
31 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 0.7 1
32 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 0.6 1
33 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 0.4 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 0.3 2
35 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 0.2 1
36 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 0.0 1
 
By Consensus (Combined)
variance against average
Top ↑
# Country Whisky variance ratings
1 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 21), 0.0 1
2 Scotch Black Bottle, 5 yo. 0.2 1
3 Scotch Caol Ila "Unpeated Malt", 12 yo. 0.3 2
4 Scotch Bruichladdich "Hart Bros Ardbeg Cask", 16 yo. 0.4 1
5 Scotch Ardbeg "Uigeadail", 0.6 1
6 American Maker's Mark "Red Seal", 0.7 1
7 Scotch Rattray's Batch No.01, 19 yo. 0.8 1
8 Scotch Kilchoman "Winter 2010 Release", 3 yo. 1.2 1
9 Scotch Balvenie "Peated Cask", 17 yo. 1.2 1
10 Scotch Glenlochy "K&L SigVin SB CS", 31 yo. 1.2 1
11 Scotch Springbank, 12 yo. 1.7 1
12 American High West "Campfire", 5 yo. 2.5 1
13 American St. George (Lot SM011), 2.6 1
14 Scotch Highland Park (New Flat Bottle), 18 yo. 2.7 1
15 Scotch GlenDronach "K&L Excl.", 19 yo. 2.7 1
16 Scotch Royal Lochnagar DE, 12 yo. 2.8 1
17 Indian Amrut "Portonova", 3.0 1
18 Scotch Aberlour "A'Bunadh" (Batch 34), 3.5 1
19 Irish Greenore "Small Batch", 8 yo. 3.6 1
20 German Gruel "Tecker", 3.9 1
21 Canadian Masterson's "Batch No. 003", 10 yo. 4.0 1
22 Scotch Laphroaig "SMWS 29.139", 18 yo. 4.5 1
23 Scotch Ardbeg "Elements of Islay - Ar1", 4.6 1
24 Scotch Shackleton's Whisky: Mackinlay's "Rare Old Highland Malt", 4.6 1
25 American St. George "Breaking & Entering", 5 yo. 4.7 1
26 Scotch Laphroaig "Elements of islay - Lp1", 5.1 1
27 Scotch Auchentoshan "Three Wood", 5.2 1
28 Scotch Ellenstown "Cask Strength Islay", 12 yo. 6.1 1
29 Scotch Bruichladdich "Infinity 3.10", 6.2 1
30 Scotch Bruichladdich "Elements of Islay - Br1", 6.3 1
31 Scotch Highland Park (Old Round Bottle), 18 yo. 6.6 1
32 Scotch Caol Ila "Elements of Islay - Cl1", 7.1 1
33 Scotch Springbank, 15 yo. 9.1 1
34 Scotch Caol Ila "ADR", 21 yo. 9.3 1
35 Scotch Clynelish "SV", 11 yo. 9.8 1
36 Scotch Balvenie "Double Wood", 12 yo. 14.0 1
Whisky Buddies & Foes
Whisky Buddies
(5 or more comparable ratings)
Top ↑
# Buddy Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Romi Said 4.0 5
2 Dan Bunn 4.9 11
3 David Drell 5.0 32
4 Anthony Lanni 5.1 25
5 Stuart Campbell 5.5 34
6 Robert Crawford 5.8 14
7 Jim Leuper 5.8 30
8 David Lawson 6.0 21
9 Kolja Erman 6.1 48
10 Andy Romine 6.2 12
11 Andrew Pilgrim 6.4 5
12 Alex Gurevich 6.4 33
13 Tom Owens 6.4 19
14 Doug Seiden 6.5 13
15 Brent Watkins 6.6 8
16 Jason McDade 6.7 13
17 Leighton Hickman 8.3 6
18 Josh Richards 8.6 10
 
Whisky Foes
(5 or more comparable ratings)
Top ↑
# Foe Variance (Pts) Shared Ratings
1 Josh Richards 8.6 10
2 Leighton Hickman 8.3 6
3 Jason McDade 6.7 13
4 Brent Watkins 6.6 8
5 Doug Seiden 6.5 13
6 Tom Owens 6.4 19
7 Alex Gurevich 6.4 33
8 Andrew Pilgrim 6.4 5
9 Andy Romine 6.2 12
10 Kolja Erman 6.1 48
11 David Lawson 6.0 21
12 Jim Leuper 5.8 30
13 Robert Crawford 5.8 14
14 Stuart Campbell 5.5 34
15 Anthony Lanni 5.1 25
16 David Drell 5.0 32
17 Dan Bunn 4.9 11
18 Romi Said 4.0 5
Graphs